Upland Columbus Pump House Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Upland Columbus Pump House, where historic charm meets culinary delight. Nestled along the picturesque White River in Columbus, IN, this restaurant showcases a vibrant menu that pays homage to local flavors.
Start your journey with shareables like the Crispy Brussels or Pork Poutine, each dish crafted for a memorable experience. If you're a fan of hearty classics, the Hoosier Tenderloin and Fish and Chips are must-tries, while the Wit Mac & Cheese provides a creamy, vegetarian indulgence.
For a fresh approach, explore their delightful salads or innovative sandwiches, like the Turkey & Guac. With generous portions and a creative selection, every visit brings a new adventure. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff ensure your experience is nothing short of exceptional, making it a perfect spot for food lovers in Columbus.
Shareables
Nachos
blue corn chips, mozzarella, and cheddar-Jack, fresh jalapenos, tomatoes, black beans, tomato-jalapeno salsa guacamole or sour cream for an additional charge. Spicy chicken, spicy beef, Southwest tofu, or BBQ pulled pork. Vegetarian and gluten-free. Add proteins and add-ons for an additional charge.
Spin Dip
toasted pita and house-fried blue corn tortilla chips. (gf) no pita. Vegetarian.
Chicharron
cripsy pig skins tossed in smoked chili seasoning, barrel-aged plum sauce
Smoked Wings
house-smoked wings, bbq sauce, pickled vegetables, horseradish parmesan dressing
Soft Pretzels
fresh, warm pretzel twists, pimento cheese spread, dragonfly IPA mustard. Vegetarian.
Truffle Fries
Brewery fries, Truffle oil, roasted garlic aioli, & Grana Padano cheese
Pork Poutine
Bad Elmer’s gravy, pulled pork, cheese curds, pickled red onions & candied jalapeños
Crispy Brussels
fried brussel sprouts, sweet chili sauce, peanuts, sesame seeds, green onions & fried wontons
Brewery Fries
beer battered and golden brown
Chips And Salsa
blue corn chips and housemade tomato-jalapeno salsa. Vegan and gluten-free.
Fried Seitan Nugs
house-made seitan, tossed in sauce, pickled vegetables & blue cheese dressing
Upland Entree Salad
field greens, sliced cucumber, carrots, cherry tomatoes, garlic cheese croutons. Vegan and gluten-free no croutons. Vegetarian.
Upland Side Salad
field greens, sliced cucumber, carrots, cherry tomatoes, garlic cheese croutons. Vegan and gluten-free no croutons. Vegetarian.
Turkey Avacado Salad
mixed greens, arugula, frisée, roasted poblano peppers, shaved parmesan, balsamic marinated tomato, egg, sunflower, & chia seed granola
Thai Tofu Salad
shredded red cabbage, bell pepper, carrot, edamame, spring mix, and scallions tossed in Thai chili vinaigrette, served with housemade spicy tofu, tomato, sliced cucumber, roasted peanuts, and crispy wontons. Vegan.
Caesar Entree Salad
caper caesar dressing, garlic parmesan croutons, shaved parmesan
Caesar Side Salad
caper caesar dressing, garlic parmesan croutons, shaved parmesan
Buffalo Chili
red frazier buffalo chili, bowls are served with sour cream, shredded cheese, chives, read onions & toasted baguette
Salads
Favorites
Hot Chicken Sandwich
Nashville-style hot chicken topped with bleu cheese coleslaw, and horseradish pickles
Hot Seitan Sandwich
Nashville-style hot Three Carrots Seitan topped with housemade pickles
Hoosier Tenderloin
an Indiana staple, hand breaded cutlet, served with chow chow, shredded lettuce, red onion, pickle chips and whole-grain mustardaise
Seitan-Derloin Sandwich
Three Carrots seitan, served with chow chow, shredded lettuce, red onion, pickle chips
Blackened Salmon BLT
applewood-peppered bacon, lettuce, tomato, & zesty garlic aioli on a brioche bun
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Fischer Farms pulled pork served with pickle chips and pickled red onions, served with choice of Bad Elmers bbq sauce, Dragonfly IPA beer cheese or campfire habenero sauce
Turkey & Guac Sandwich
house smoked turkey, cheddar cheese, chipotle aioli, fresh guacamole, apple wood-peppered bacon, with lettuce, tomato, & red onion on a rustic baguette
The Cuban
Fischer Farms pulled pork, sliced ham, pickle chips, Swiss cheese & mojo sauce on a rustic baguette
Fish And Chips
1/2 lb. beer-battered cod and housemade tartar sauce. Recommended with brewery fries.
Wit Mac & Cheese
cavatappi pasta, sauteed garlic, upland wheat ale, fresh cream, mozzarella, and cheddar-Jack, seasoned bread crumbs with toasted garlic baguette. Vegetarian.
Beer Roasted Salmon
fresh Canadian salmon, chili BBQ sauce, basmati rice, zucchini medley & pickled cucumber
Smoked Pork Chop
8 oz Fischer Farms pork chop, fingerling potatoes, broccolini & sorghum mustard sauce
Steak Frites
10 oz Fischer Farms grilled New York Strip, horseradish garlic butter & brewery fries
3 Little PIGS
housemade tenderloin, Fischer Farms pulled pork, peppered bacon, gouda cheese, red onion and Bad Elmers bbq sauce
3 Little TWIGS
Three Carrots seitan tenderloin, fried tofu, ground impossible chorizo, red onion and Bad Elmers bbq sauce
Classic
choice of American, cheddar, Swiss, smoked gouda or jalapeño pepper jack, lettuce, tomato & onion
Bad Elmer's
cheddar, smoked pepper bacon, Bad Elmer’s BBQ, lettuce, tomato & onion
Blue Flame
blue cheese jalapeño spread, lettuce, tomato & onion
Inferno
jalapeño pepper jack, banana peppers, Campside habanero sauce, lettuce, tomato & onion
Beer Cheese
smoked pepper bacon, Dragonfly beer cheese & grilled onions
Sweet Plum
smoked gouda, smoked pepper bacon, arugula & sweet plum sauce
Americana
American cheese, red onion, dill pickles, shredded lettuce & Champagne Velvet sauce
Burgers
Pizza Columbus
Margherita
almond – basil pesto, fresh tomato, and mozzarella cheese. Finished with balsamic drizzle.
Ron Swanson
smoked ham, bacon, local sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella, & marinara
Cheese Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
roasted chicken, bacon, jalapeños, red onion, cheddar, mozzarella & Bad Elmer’s BBQ
Side Trail Pizza
Harissa tomato sauce, falafel, red onion, tomato, mozzarella, arugula, and tzatziki
Water
Coke
Diet Coke
Sprite
Root Beer
Lemonade
Iced Tea
Sweet Iced Tea
Coffee
Hot Tea
Milk 16oz Glass
Mr. Pibb
Cherry Coke
OJ
Nitro Coffee
N/A Bev
Dessert
Warm Chocolate Brownie
4 Birds Bakery Chocolate Brownie, whipped cream, mint & Bad Elmer's Caramel
Bread Pudding
warm bread pudding with whipped cream, mint & sour cherry sauce
Kids Cheeseburger
Fischer Farms beef, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese, toasted bun, & a pickle spear served with choice of fries or cup of fruit
Kids Impossible Burger
Fischer Farms beef, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese, toasted bun, & a pickle spear served with choice of fries or cup of fruit
Kids Chicken Tenders
Kids Pulled Pork
Fischer Farms pulled pork with bbq sauce served with choice of fries or cup of fruit
Kids Tenderloin
Fischer Farms beef, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese, toasted bun, & a pickle spear served with choice of fries or cup of fruit
Kids Turkey Sandwich
Fischer Farms beef, lettuce, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese, toasted bun, & a pickle spear served with choice of fries or cup of fruit
Kids Fish & Chips
batter cod with homemade tartar sauce served with fries or fresh fruit
Kids Mac & Cheese
cavatappi pasta, fresh cream, mozzarella and cheddar-jack cheese, seasoned bread crumbs served with toasted baguette
Kids Pizza
fresh dough, house-made red sauce & cheese
Mini Chocolate Brownie
4 Birds Bakery Chocolate Brownies, whipped cream, mint & Bad Elmer's Caramel